Chicago - May. 14, 2021
Music TV Politics Sports Books People Places & Things
Beachwood Politics
Our monthly archive.
Who We Are
Chicago by the numbers.
Sausage Links
Wiki Daley
Wiki Rahm
Illinois Channel
Ralph Martire
Government Attic
Division Street
Indie Political Report
The Obameter
The Intercept
American Dream Betrayed

Smithfield's Pork PR Scam

Smithfield is the country's largest pork producer - and one of its biggest industrial polluters. But they don't want you to think of them that way. Instead, the company likes to promote a conscientious, sustainable, family-farmer image, summed up with a simple catchphrase: "Good Food. Responsibly."

In reality, the corporate giant relies on a sprawling network of polluting factory farms and slaughterhouses, responsible for widespread pollution of our air and water. And one of Smithfield's most aggressive clean image initiatives relies on - if you can believe it - massive, leaky lagoons of pig manure.

shutterstock_1074925286-1000x675.jpgA pig manure lagoon/Shutterstock

That yawning gap between the company's carefully crafted image and its record of environmental degradation is why Food & Water Watch, joined by several other farming and environmental groups, filed a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission over Smithfield's deceptive and misleading advertising.

Smithfield tells consumers that its products are "Sustainable from Farm to Fork," with marketing materials featuring sunny, bucolic farms. Smithfield insists that "Environmental stewardship is a key focus for everyone at Smithfield Foods."

The facts say otherwise.

Smithfield is the third-largest water polluter in the country. In 2019, the company was issued at least 66 notices of violations of environmental protection laws.

That's especially true in North Carolina, where earlier this year state regulators called out the company over massive spills of hog waste. The company's waste mismanagement - from spills and water contamination to the intentional spraying of manure - have led hundreds of local residents to join nuisance lawsuits, leading to tens of millions of dollars in jury awards against Smithfield.

Smithfield's pig poop problem is staggering - its facilities create an estimated 19 million tons of the stuff every year. But instead of cleaning up after itself, the company (like other factory farm corporate giants) is trying to sell the idea that their massive lagoons of pig manure aren't a pollution problem - they're actually a clean source of "renewable" energy.

Come again?

Smithfield's huge lagoons of manure release large quantities of methane, a highly potent greenhouse gas, into the atmosphere. These methane emissions are a result of how factory farms manage animal waste. More sustainable farming practices don't have this problem.

But instead of cleaning up their act, these giant corporations want to profit from it. The idea is that a machine called a "digester" can capture a lagoon's methane emissions, which can then be refined and rebranded as "renewable" natural gas.

For one thing, Smithfield's digester projects are essentially gas refineries. So they're also sources of dangerous air pollutants in places already overburdened with other sources of pollution. For another, the digesters are expensive and prone to explosions and spills. And the gas pipelines they'd feed often leak methane themselves.

Even if the scheme actually works, the poop problem doesn't disappear. In fact, the waste products left over after the digestion process can be even more environmentally hazardous than the original manure.

Finally, burning factory farm biogas releases harmful pollutants like carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides, ammonia and sulfur dioxide into the air.

What we have, when all is said and done, is not a solution. It's a cover-up.

A profitable company like Smithfield should clean up its act. In fact, the company agreed to improve its handling of pig waste in North Carolina 20 years ago, but very little has changed. Promoting so-called biogas digesters is just another way to expand and entrench their factory farm model, which puts a squeeze on small farms and inflicts pollution on their neighbors.

Smithfield seems to think it can slap on a sustainability slogan and sell consumers a fairy tale about "renewable gas." For the sake of small family farms, local residents, and truly sustainable farming methods, we need to put a stop to this corporate charade.


Previously in Smithfield:

* What I Watched Last Night, April 30, 2010: "One of these corporations that caught the attention of Food, Inc. was Smithfield, which runs the world's largest hog processing plant in Tar Heel, North Carolina. The plant blows through 32,000 hogs a day and has the benefit of a seemingly bottomless supply of disposable, low-skilled immigrants - many bused in from within a 100-mile radius - to do one of the most dangerous jobs in the country for the kind of wages George Pullman would envy."

* Random Food Report: Chimps, Footlongs & China, July 9, 2013: "The impending sale of Virginia-based pork producer Smithfield Foods to Chinese meat company Shuanghui International has caught the attention of a diverse cross-section of the food industry in the U.S., from food safety experts and disturbed consumer rights groups to senators concerned with the implications of the deal . . . "

* The [Friday] Papers, April 16, 2020: "Earlier this week, Smithfield Foods shut down facilities in three different state including it's Sioux Falls, South Dakota location. The plant was shut down after 598 employees tested positive for the coronavirus, as well as an additional 135 people who are not employed by the company, but contracted the virus after they were in close contact with the workers.

"The processing facility supplies 5 percent of the nation's pork supply and the anonymous [South Side] Rose Packing Co. employee says Smithfield is one of the company's suppliers."

* Millions Of Essential Workers Are Being Left Out Of COVID-19 Workplace Safety Protections, Thanks To OSHA, April 16, 2020: "In recent days, many of the largest outbreaks have been at work, highlighted by the spread of the disease to more than 600 workers at Smithfield Foods' pork processing plant in Sioux Falls, South Dakota . . . "

* The [Monday] Papers, April 27, 2020: "Meat-processing giant Smithfield Foods is closing two of its facilities in Illinois, its latest moves to shut down meatpacking plants due to the coronavirus pandemic . . . "

* E-Mails Reveal Disgusting Meatpacking Shitshow Over COVID-19 Outbreaks, June 12, 2020: "In mid-March, a few weeks before a massive outbreak at its South Dakota pork plant, Smithfield Foods' chief executive Kenneth Sullivan sent a letter to Nebraska Gov. Pete Ricketts saying he had 'grave concerns' that stay-at-home orders were causing 'hysteria.'"

* The [Thursday] Papers, July 16, 2020: "In the days before the Kane County Health Department ordered Smithfield Foods' St. Charles meat processing plant to close due to concerns about COVID-19, and before the health department confirmed an employee had died, a call came in to police . . . "


Comments welcome.


Posted on February 25, 2021

MUSIC - Stock Music Market On Fire.
TV - BMW Is The Answer.
POLITICS - The Fed Is Making The Rich Richer.
SPORTS - White Sox Beating Manager.

BOOKS - Reassessing Mandela.

PEOPLE PLACES & THINGS - Dinosaur Drive-Thru!

Search The Beachwood Reporter

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Follow BeachwoodReport on Twitter

Beachwood Radio!